An Honest Comparison by American Builder Hardwood Floor

Introduction

When it comes to flooring, the debate between traditional hardwood and modern luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is a common one for homeowners. Both offer a beautiful foundation for your home, but they have distinct differences in composition, durability, maintenance, and cost. As flooring experts serving Quincy, MA, and the Greater Boston area, American Builder Hardwood Floor is here to provide a clear comparison to help you make an informed decision.

1. Composition and Authenticity

The most fundamental difference lies in what they're made of.

• Hardwood: Solid hardwood flooring is made from 100% real wood, milled directly from harvested trees. Engineered hardwood consists of a real wood veneer over a plywood core. It offers authentic, unique grain patterns, and natural warmth.
• LVP: Luxury Vinyl Plank is a multi-layered synthetic product. It consists of a durable PVC core, a high-definition printed image layer that mimics wood, and a protective wear layer. While modern LVP is incredibly realistic, it is ultimately a replica.

Winner for Authenticity: Hardwood.

2. Durability and Water Resistance

This is where LVP often shines, especially in challenging environments.

• Hardwood: While durable, hardwood is susceptible to scratches, dents, and, most importantly, water damage. Humidity, spills, and moisture can cause it to warp, cup, or stain. It is not recommended for bathrooms or basements.
• LVP: LVP is 100% waterproof, making it an excellent choice for kitchens, bathrooms, basements, and any area prone to spills or moisture. Its top wear layer is also highly resistant to scratches and scuffs, making it a great option for homes with pets and young children.

Winner for Water Resistance & Scratch Resistance: LVP.

3. Maintenance and Care

Both floors are relatively easy to clean, but their long-term maintenance needs differ significantly.

• Hardwood: Requires specific pH-neutral cleaners and must be protected from excessive water. The major advantage of hardwood is its ability to be refinished. When it becomes scratched or worn after years of use, it can be sanded down and restored to look brand new, a process that can be repeated multiple times over its lifespan.
• LVP: Can be cleaned with a wider variety of products and is not sensitive to water. However, if a plank is deeply scratched or damaged, it cannot be refinished. The individual plank must be replaced.

Winner for Low-Maintenance Cleaning: LVP.
Winner for Longevity & Repairability: Hardwood.

4. Cost and Installation

Budget is a major factor for any home improvement project.

• Hardwood: Generally has a higher upfront cost for both materials and installation. The price varies widely depending on the wood species and whether it's solid or engineered.
• LVP: Is typically more affordable than hardwood. The material itself is less expensive, and installation is often faster and less labor-intensive, especially with "floating" click-lock systems.

Winner for Budget-Friendliness: LVP.

5. Resale Value

For many, a home is an investment, and flooring can impact its value.

• Hardwood: Is consistently cited by real estate agents as a top feature that increases home value. It is seen as a premium, long-term investment that is highly desirable to buyers.
• LVP: While high-quality LVP is a significant upgrade over old carpet or sheet vinyl, it does not typically add the same long-term resale value as authentic hardwood.

Winner for Resale Value: Hardwood.

Why Choose American Builder Hardwood Floor?

While our name is American Builder Hardwood Floor, we are experts in all types of flooring. We believe in giving our clients honest, practical advice to help them choose the best material for their specific needs, budget, and lifestyle in the unique New England climate.

Conclusion

The choice between LVP and hardwood depends on your priorities. If your primary concerns are budget, water resistance, and low-maintenance durability in a busy home, LVP is an outstanding choice. If you prioritize authenticity, long-term investment, the ability to refinish, and increasing your home's resale value, hardwood remains the gold standard. Contact American Builder Hardwood Floor today, and let our experts help you make the perfect choice.